Is Protein Water as Good as a Meal?

Dr. Oz has the answer.

More From Ask Dr. Oz Anything
20 articles
putting on earring
Why Do Some People's Ear Piercings Stretch?
healthy baked potato
Is There Such a Thing as a Healthy Baked Potato?
flavored vinegars
Are Flavored Vinegars High in Sugar?

Q: Protein water — as good as a meal?

Oz Says: Technically, your body could meet its protein needs from these drinks. They have about 15 grams of the nutrient per bottle (16.9 ounce), the same amount you'd get from a quarter of a roasted chicken breast, two 5-ounce low-fat yogurts, or a cup of cooked black beans. But you don't want to rely too much on the liquid stuff.

"That would mean missing out on key nutrients, like B vitamins, that are found in many high-protein foods," says Lisa Young, PhD, RD, an adjunct professor of nutrition at New York University.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Plus, fast-digesting liquid protein doesn't satisfy you like an actual meal does; chewing and having food move through the digestive process contributes to feelings of fullness. So protein water and salad for lunch could leave you with vending-machine temptation soon after. And adding one of these drinks to an already protein-rich diet could put you over the top on calories from this nutrient, which can pile on pounds and stress your kidneys, Young says.

More From Ask Dr. Oz Anything
20 articles
putting on earring
Why Do Some People's Ear Piercings Stretch?
healthy baked potato
Is There Such a Thing as a Healthy Baked Potato?
flavored vinegars
Are Flavored Vinegars High in Sugar?
green tea oolong tea
Is Green Tea as Good for You as Oolong?
sneezing
Can Anything Help Bring On a Sneeze?

Bottom line: You really can't bottle all the benefits of a tasty, chewable meal.

This story originally appeared in the June 2016 issue of Dr. Oz The Good Life.

The hottest ticket in daytime TV can be yours. Make your free appointment to see The Dr. Oz Show in NYC: www.doctoroz.com/tickets


SUBSCRIBE TO DR. OZ THE GOOD LIFE

Get the Print & Digital Editions and Save 81%! You'll receive instant access to the latest issue before it hits the newsstands.

Order Now


More from Dr Oz The Good Life: